Can I keep a cross necklace from my grandma?
It depends on what you do with it. You shouldn't wear it, because the cross is a central religious symbol of another faith. Keeping it is where scholars differ: many advise against keeping a cross, while some are more lenient about storing it away as a family keepsake. Many converts find a gentle middle way that honors their grandma.
Why not wear it?
The cross represents beliefs that Islam doesn't share, namely that Jesus was crucified and is divine. Muslims love and honor Jesus (Isa) as a prophet, but wearing a cross would signal a belief you no longer hold.
What about keeping it?
Aisha said that the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ would not leave anything in his house that carried crosses without removing them (Sahih al-Bukhari 5952). Based on this, many scholars advise not keeping crosses at home.
Some scholars are more lenient about an item that's stored away, never displayed or worn, especially when it carries family meaning. If you're unsure, ask a scholar you trust.
Gentle options many converts choose
- Pass it on in the family. Give it to a Christian relative, like a cousin or aunt, who will treasure it. Grandma's necklace stays in the family.
- Reshape it. A jeweler can turn the metal into a different pendant or a ring. You keep the material and the memory, without the symbol. (Men: remember gold isn't for wearing, see Can Muslim men wear gold rings?)
- Keep the memory, not the object. A photo of your grandma wearing it can mean just as much.
Your grandma's feelings matter
Islam asks you to treat family with kindness, even when you don't share their faith. If your grandma is still alive, don't let the necklace become a hurtful moment. You might say, "I love it because it's from you, and I want it to stay in the family." For more on staying close to family, see Can I celebrate my birthday after becoming Muslim?
And if it's a memento of a grandparent who has passed away, take your time. You don't have to decide everything in your first week as a Muslim.
- Don't wear a cross as a Muslim.
- Many scholars advise not keeping crosses at home.
- Giving it to a relative or reshaping it are good options.
- Handle it with kindness toward your family.
Comments (0)
Please keep it kind and respectful.